Think about the last time you wanted to ask a question but decided against it.
Maybe you were worried it would sound stupid.
Perhaps you had an idea during a meeting but kept it to yourself because you weren't sure how others would respond.
Or maybe you were learning something new and felt embarrassed about making a mistake in front of other people.
These experiences are incredibly common, and they highlight an important psychological concept: psychological safety.
Psychological safety influences our willingness to ask questions, seek feedback, acknowledge mistakes, and participate in unfamiliar experiences.
Understanding how it works can help us become better leaders, teammates, coaches, and learners.
What Is Psychological Safety?
Harvard researcher Amy Edmondson defines psychological safety as a shared belief that a team is safe for interpersonal risk-taking.
In practical terms, it means people feel comfortable speaking up, asking questions, admitting mistakes, and expressing concerns without expecting humiliation or punishment simply for doing so.
In her 1999 study of work teams, Edmondson found that psychological safety was associated with learning behaviors, including seeking feedback, discussing errors, and experimenting with new approaches.
These behaviors are essential for improvement.
When people feel comfortable acknowledging what they don't know, they create opportunities to learn.
When they feel comfortable discussing mistakes, teams gain information that can help prevent those mistakes from happening again.
Psychological safety encourages the open communication that makes learning possible.
Why Fear Interferes With Learning
Learning requires vulnerability.
We have to acknowledge that we don't know something, attempt unfamiliar tasks, and accept that we may make mistakes along the way.
When people anticipate embarrassment, rejection, or criticism, they may become reluctant to take those risks.
Consider an employee who notices a potential problem but remains silent because previous concerns have been dismissed.
Or an athlete who doesn't understand a movement but avoids asking for clarification because everyone else appears to know what they're doing.
In both situations, the fear of judgment interferes with the opportunity to learn or prevent a problem.
Research on psychological safety suggests that supportive interpersonal environments encourage people to share information, ask for help, and participate more actively in learning.
Psychological Safety and Accountability
One of the most important distinctions to understand is that psychological safety and accountability can coexist.
People can feel respected and supported while still being expected to meet high standards.
In fact, Edmondson's work emphasizes the importance of combining psychological safety with accountability to create environments that support learning and performance.
A psychologically safe environment allows people to acknowledge mistakes and take responsibility for correcting them.
For example, imagine two coaches responding to an athlete who repeatedly struggles with a movement.
One becomes visibly frustrated and criticizes the athlete in front of the class.
The other identifies the technical issue, explains the correction, and provides an opportunity to practice.
Both coaches may expect the athlete to improve.
Their approaches create very different learning experiences.
Constructive feedback maintains expectations while giving people the information and confidence to continue developing.
Why Psychological Safety Matters in Fitness
As a CrossFit coach and personal trainer, I think about psychological safety often.
Walking into a gym for the first time can be intimidating.
There are unfamiliar movements, equipment, terminology, and people who may appear much more experienced.
For someone who is already nervous about exercising, the possibility of embarrassment can become a significant barrier.
A supportive coaching environment can help reduce that barrier.
Athletes should feel comfortable:
Asking questions about movements or programming.
Admitting when they don't understand something.
Communicating pain, fatigue, or limitations.
Scaling workouts to their current abilities.
Receiving feedback and practicing unfamiliar skills.
Celebrating progress at their own pace.
When athletes feel comfortable communicating openly, coaches can make more informed decisions about training.
That communication supports learning, appropriate exercise selection, and long-term participation.
The way we respond to questions, mistakes, and limitations influences whether people feel comfortable bringing them to our attention again.
The Role of Leadership
Psychological safety is especially important in leadership.
Leaders influence how people interpret mistakes, disagreements, and uncertainty.
When leaders respond defensively to questions or criticism, others may become less willing to speak openly.
When leaders acknowledge their own mistakes, invite feedback, and demonstrate a willingness to learn, they help establish expectations for how the group communicates.
This requires consistency.
A leader who encourages questions but responds impatiently when someone asks one sends conflicting messages.
People pay attention to behavior.
Over time, repeated interactions establish whether an environment genuinely supports open communication.
Psychological Safety Strengthens Teams
Teams depend on communication, cooperation, and trust.
Whether we're discussing a workplace, athletic team, or community organization, people need to exchange information and coordinate their efforts.
Psychological safety supports those processes by making it easier for individuals to raise concerns, share ideas, and discuss problems.
For example, imagine a sports team where players are afraid to acknowledge mistakes.
Communication may suffer because individuals are focused on avoiding blame.
A team that can openly discuss what went wrong has more opportunities to identify solutions and improve its performance.
Research has linked psychological safety with team learning and, under certain conditions, improved performance.
The relationship is influenced by factors such as leadership, team structure, and the nature of the work, but the underlying principle is valuable: teams benefit when members can communicate openly and constructively.
How to Create Psychological Safety
Psychological safety develops through repeated interactions.
A few intentional behaviors can help strengthen it.
1. Encourage Questions
Make it clear that asking for clarification is welcome.
When someone asks a question, respond with patience and useful information.
2. Respond Constructively to Mistakes
Focus on understanding what happened and identifying the next step.
Feedback should help people improve their behavior or performance.
3. Model Accountability
Acknowledge your own mistakes and demonstrate how you learn from them.
Leaders and coaches establish powerful examples through their actions.
4. Invite Different Perspectives
Encourage people to share ideas, concerns, and alternative approaches.
Listen carefully before responding, especially when someone challenges your assumptions.
5. Maintain Clear Expectations
Communicate standards, responsibilities, and boundaries.
People benefit from understanding what is expected and how their performance will be evaluated.
6. Recognize Effort and Improvement
Acknowledge thoughtful questions, constructive feedback, and progress.
Reinforcing these behaviors encourages continued participation and learning.
Psychological Safety and Resilience
Resilience involves adapting to challenges, learning from experience, and accessing resources when we need support.
Psychological safety can strengthen these processes by creating environments where people feel comfortable communicating difficulties and seeking assistance.
Someone who feels safe acknowledging a problem is better positioned to address it.
A team that can discuss setbacks openly has more opportunities to adapt.
An athlete who feels comfortable communicating limitations can work with their coach to make appropriate adjustments.
Supportive environments contribute to the conditions in which resilience can develop.
The Bigger Picture
Every interaction provides an opportunity to influence the environment around us.
The way we respond when someone asks a question.
The feedback we provide after a mistake.
Our willingness to acknowledge uncertainty.
The respect we show when someone disagrees.
These everyday behaviors shape whether people feel comfortable learning, communicating, and participating.
Psychological safety creates space for people to challenge themselves, develop new skills, and take responsibility for their growth.
When we combine that environment with clear expectations and constructive accountability, we create opportunities for meaningful improvement.
People are more willing to grow when they trust that learning won't cost them their dignity.
Reflection Prompt: How do your reactions to other people's questions, mistakes, or disagreements influence their willingness to communicate openly with you?
Selected References
Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383.
Edmondson, A. C. (2019). The Fearless Organization: Creating Psychological Safety in the Workplace for Learning, Innovation, and Growth. Wiley.
Frazier, M. L., Fainshmidt, S., Klinger, R. L., Pezeshkan, A., & Vracheva, V. (2017). Psychological safety: A meta-analytic review and extension. Personnel Psychology, 70(1), 113–165.
Newman, A., Donohue, R., & Eva, N. (2017). Psychological safety: A systematic review of the literature. Human Resource Management Review, 27(3), 521–535.